Even mildly sleepy physicians and nurses make mistakes, and our patients may be suffering.
Sleep...that magical, mystical and misunderstood process, which is
as important as food and water, but often cast aside as a disposable
commodity in our busy 24/7 world. Remember when you were 10 years old
and could "sleep like a rock"? As Rudyard Kipling put it in Captains
Courageous, "That 40-fathom slumber that clears the soul, the eye and
heart, and sends you to breakfast ravening." I, for one, would like to
experience that again--at least once in awhile!
Since the
development of Edison's light bulb, our average nightly sleep period
has fallen off steadily, dropping from about nine hours to about seven
hours. We are a sleep-deprived society, and the medical profession is
its "poster child," with pride in its legacy of long, sleepless nights
caring for patients. Through our training and into our current
practices, long hours and little sleep are often worn as badge of
distinction. But at what cost to our patients and ourselves?
Memory,
cognitive ability and performance are intimately linked to the quality
and quantity of sleep. Who among us doesn't rely on these in daily
duties? We pay the price for lack of sleep in many ways, some obvious
and others quite subtle.
Most of us truly do need between seven and
a half to eight hours of normal sleep (quantity, quality and timing) to
feel and function at our best. Grandma was right! And current,
evidence--based medicine proves it.
Recent, well-designed studies
reveal that sleeping fewer than six hours per night over a period of 14
days produces the same neurocognitive and performance deficits as two
consecutive nights of no sleep at all. (Remember what you were like the
day after those all-nighters while studying for exams or being
on-call?) Executive brain function, judgment and the ability to
personally recognize the deficits in performance are astoundingly poor.
Like the drunk behind the wheel, you feel like you still have it
together as you drive off the road. Mood, family life and social
interactions suffer. Immune function is impaired and metabolic
alterations favor weight gain when we don't get enough sleep. Our
quality of life suffers and we have a much higher suicide rate than the
general population.
Recent polls show that doctors get an average of
six-and-a-half hours of sleep per night and our average work day is ten
to thirteen hours. We try to sleep more on weekends and days off. We
drink more caffeine than the average American--but say it's just a
"habit" and don't really need it to "keep awake."
So with all of
that in mind, what does that mean for our patients? Despite our best
intentions, even mildly sleepy physicians and nurses make mistakes and
our patients may be suffering more than we recognize.
We are
beginning to awaken to the problem. Recognizing that sleep deprivation
is a way of life in medical training programs, and as such, is likely
endangering patient safety, the Accreditation Council for Graduate
Medical Education implemented some positive, though anemic,
restrictions. These include an 80-hour work-week limit and a 30-hour
limit on continuous shifts.
Yet there is much more we can do.
Despite current manpower limitations in the health industry, clinics
and hospitals could benefit by optimizing shift-work rotations, and
implementing limitations on the total number of hours worked each week.
Doctor coverage schedules could be adjusted to avoid the all-week or
all-weekend shifts, when possible. Malpractice carriers could track
work hours and sleepiness factors in their claims database, promoting
good sleep habits as a reasonable way to reduce malpractice claims.
We
know that when the call comes, we've got to be there for our patients.
But for your own health and well-being, for your patients' safety and
care and to limit potential malpractice suits, take the time--make the
time--for sleep.