Local physicians donate their medical expertise in humanitarian missions abroad, serving those in need and rejuvenating themselves in the process.
Local physicians donate their medical expertise in humanitarian
missions abroad, serving those in need and rejuvenating themselves in
the process.
"I get a lump in my throat all the time when I tell this story," says
Sudeep Kukreja, MD, a neonatologist at Children's Hospital of Orange
County and a UCLA assistant professor of pediatrics, recalling his most
memorable experience as a medical volunteer with Operation Smile,
treating disadvantaged patients in a foreign country.
In the large coastal city of Fortaleza in northeastern Brazil, Dr.
Kukreja and colleagues watched as about 1,800 mothers, fathers and
children from the surrounding area learned who would undergo cleft
palate surgery the next day, from a list posted outside the hospital.
"They're waiting to see their child's name on that list," recounts Dr.
Kukreja. "When they see their name, there are people who are just
screaming with joy, tears in their eyes. And there are people who are
crying--again tears in their eyes--because their kid's name is not there."
As Dr. Kukreja stood watching the scene play out, a young woman
approached him from out of the crowd to thank him through a
Portuguese-speaking interpreter. She had just seen her 5-year-old son's
name on the list of patients who the medical team felt were strong
enough to take anesthesia. The boy was slated for surgery to correct
his cleft lip and palate on the very next day. In a cracking voice, Dr.
Kukreja recalls the woman's next words: "We traveled 300 miles. From
the same village, there's a girl with me who is 16 years old. She does
not have any friends, because of her facial deformity, because of the
cleft lip and cleft palate. Nobody wants to talk to her; nobody wants
to be friends with her. And probably, she will never get married
because of her facial deformity."
The girl's name was not on the list. "What if I take my son's name off
the list," offered the woman, "can you do surgery for her?"
"I said, 'Lady, God bless you,' and this really brought my heart to the
bottom--to my boots, really," Dr. Kukreja says. "And guess what? We call
it 'God,' that's where the 'God' was. [The girl's] name was wrongly
spelled there. And she also had the surgery done."
The heartrending and poignant aspects of volunteering one's medical
services outside the United States don't deter physicians--they actually
attract participants. Those who go abroad to give first-world medical
care want to help people who might otherwise never receive treatment.
These medical volunteers treasure their experiences and even find the
intense labor refreshing. Dr. Kukreja, for example, apparently cannot
get enough. After more than a dozen expeditions with the organizations
Operation Smile, the International Relief Team and Project Vietnam, he
created his own such group, called Arpan Global Charities, three years
ago.
According to the medical volunteers themselves--sometimes called
"medical missionaries"--they are motivated by reasons both altruistic
and selfish, but above all they want to help. And in the process, some
feel they become better doctors as they experience the essence of the
profession.
The impact medical volunteers have upon the public health in foreign
lands is surprisingly difficult to quantify, but it's clear that they
make a difference in the individual lives of people who might not have
anyone else to turn to.
Remembering Others
"I'm from Burma--Myanmar--which is considered one of the poorest
countries now, with 50 million people. It's very depressed, very
oppressed," says Aisha Simjee, MD. An ophthalmologist based in Orange,
Dr. Simjee recently returned from an October medical mission to
Colombia with CHOC colleague Dr. Kukreja and his group, Arpan Global
Charities. "I left [Myanmar] 37 years ago, and I thought, 'As soon as I stand on my feet and I have enough
resources to go out of the country and do it ... I will.' That time
arrived in 1991," she explains.
For many doctors who managed to escape deprivation, medical
volunteerism offers a way to throw a lifeline to people who weren't so
lucky. "I was able to get out of the country; I was able to come to
America; I was blessed to go into a field that I wanted to go [into],"
Dr. Simjee says. "I have everything I need: a house; a car; three meals
a day. I don't need anything more than what I have, so I have to find
time to go out and help."
After more than 16 years of medical volunteerism, Dr. Simjee has
visited 21 countries, including El Salvador, Ethiopia and Afghanistan,
and she has stories to tell about each of them. "There's something
memorable about every country I've been to," she says. For example,
traveling with Roger Ohanesian, MD, and the Armenian EyeCare Project,
Dr. Simjee was stopped in the airport of Yerevan, the capital city, by
customs agents who were suspicious of her box of frozen corneas. "They
said, 'We'll let you have it in two to three days,'" she recalls. "I
said, 'No way--I'm running out of my dry-ice time, and I must take it
with me.' They were confused, so they left the box outside the customs
[office], and all the officers went in for a meeting to see what to do
with me. So I took the box and I left!"
Vien Doan, DO, a family practitioner in Riverside, offers similar
motivations. Born and reared in Vietnam, he came to the United States
at 16 years old after the end of the war. "I felt very lonely and lost,
then I found a direction for my life," Dr. Doan says. "When I began
college in 1977, I thought that if I were to go back to Vietnam one day
to help take care of the people I left behind, that would also give
them the peace that I got when I was here," he says. "I felt that
although I didn't deserve it, I got a much better life than the people
who I left behind."
So, when an influx of Vietnamese immigrants came to Orange County, he
helped found Nhan Hoa Clinic in Garden Grove, and served there until
1994. By 2000, he had put together a team of four volunteers for his
first medical mission to Vietnam under his group, the Good Samaritan
Medical Ministry. Two teams now go to Vietnam every year, a team of
about 70 primary care doctors and a separate team of specialists. Since
2005, his teams have trained local doctors at Hue Medical College in
Imperial City in emergency medicine, and now aim to start a residency
program.
Answering the Call of Missionary Work
Volunteering helps physicians express the drives that first propelled
them to go into medicine. "Medicine always called me to make a
difference in people's lives, and to bring an opportunity for health,
energy and well-being to people," says Gordon Phillips, MD, a primary
care practitioner in Redlands who flies with Liga International in
small, private planes to clinics in Tijuana, Mexico, and further south
to the area surrounding El Fuerte, a city in the state of Sinaloa. "We
often get caught up in a lot of monetary things here in the United
States," he says. "To be able to volunteer time and see that it makes a
real difference and [that] people are so appreciative of it, it's just
very rewarding."
Dr. Phillips first became interested in Liga International as an eighth
grader, when he flew on one of its trips to the state of Sonora,
Mexico. Roughly four decades later, he took his first trip as a
physician. "Seeing people willing to stand outside, sleep outside and
just wait to be seen by a doctor--it struck me what a need there was,"
he says. In the past four years, he has been on about a dozen trips,
and he visits two to four times a year. Each weekend, a group of about
70 Liga volunteers flies to the El Fuerte area to see about 1,000
patients. The volunteers include a dozen or more doctors, as well as
nurses, translators, dentists, medical students, psychologists and
others.
Dr. Kukreja describes his motives for going on medical missions as
paradoxically selfish. "We say it's a volunteer mission, but that
defeats the definition of volunteerism, because volunteer means when
you give something or do something without getting paid or getting a
benefit," he says. "But here, there's always a benefit--one no money can
buy you. It's for your own satisfaction. That's why it's not
volunteerism."
Finding Inspiration and Energy
Medical missions are part of Dr. Kukreja's vacations, and he describes
them as hard work, with some shifts as long as 16 hours. But somehow,
it's not like just another day at the office. "You feel really
rejuvenated after coming home from this kind of mission," he says. "And
that's just because you like it, because you love doing these things.
It's an immensely rewarding experience, really. It's really fantastic."
"I feel wonderful," proclaims Dr. Simjee when asked whether she finds her work in third-world countries tiring. "Every time I have gone, I have felt that every minute I spent and every cent I spent was worth it--no regrets whatsoever."
Dr. Phillips describes his feelings about medical missions similarly:
"Actually, they're very refreshing." While the work is often hard, it's
for a good cause that he finds reinvigorating. Also, the volunteers can
do adventurous things with their free time, such as visit local
restaurants and go on day trips. "[We've] gone to the large bay about
halfway down on the Baja Peninsula where the whales all spend the
winter and calf," he says. "Sometimes we'll spend an extra two days and
go into the Copper Canyon [in Sinaloa] to just relax and enjoy, spend
the night and do some hikes."
Focusing on Medicine's Essence
Treating patients in foreign countries not only helps doctors satisfy
their interest in serving humanity, it cultivates an appreciation for
what they have and changes their perspectives in unexpected ways. Dr.
Doan recalls seeing a shoeless elderly woman patient who took the day
off from working in the fields to visit him. "I sat in my chair at that
time, looking at her, and it could've been the reverse if I had not
left the country," he says. "[Patients] literally travel on foot for
four hours to come and see me. Knowing that they've been there for such
a long time, that they've taken time out to come and see me, my desire
is to do everything I can for patients right there."
Dr. Doan's patients in the United States aren't so different, he says. "I've changed my attitude completely. I do not want my patients to wait any longer than necessary in the office. When they come to see me that day, I want to make sure that I take care of them--I give them everything I can."
In Santa Ana, El Salvador, Dr. Simjee treated a group of unusual patients who she later found out were political prisoners. "Local ophthalmologists, for whatever reason, didn't want to operate on them. A number of them were very young people, and with traumatic cataracts," she says. "That motivated me to work even harder, because I wanted to take care of them as much as I could."
For many medical volunteers, practicing in a foreign country is a chance to treat patients without spending a disproportionate amount of time on paperwork or financial and regulatory concerns. The trips afford "not a little freedom--a lot of freedom," Dr. Simjee says. "We do exactly what we must do--the very best we can," she says. "Still, if something goes wrong, which can happen, they're not going to come after you and sue you. But that's not the case in America. I don't have to spend $2,000 to go to Ethiopia. I can go to Southeast Los Angeles and do as much work, but if something goes wrong, I'm liable."
"It's a business in the United States," Dr. Phillips says. "There's
always the time constraint--not that we don't get rushed in Mexico, but
there's nobody saying, 'You've got to see so many people per hour,'" he
says. "You don't have to practice all this defensive medicine that we
end up wasting a lot of time and effort on in the United States--not
that some of it isn't good, but we have a lot of waste in our system
from that kind of thing and from excess testing to cover yourself." The
challenges of working in the third world also exercise neglected
skills, he says. Without X-ray machines or CT scanners, "you're having
to actually listen to the patient and make a diagnosis and treat," Dr.
Phillips says.
Fostering Professional Collegiality
The camaraderie that develops among medical professionals during these
missions is another big benefit to volunteers, Dr. Phillips says. "One
of the neat things about going with Liga is that 70 to 80 people
[participate]," he says. "There is a huge variety of unique, talented
and gifted people. They are not all doctors; there are psychologists,
veterinarians and other people with all kinds of interests. And it's
just fun. You get to know them and see how they are really dedicated to
making whatever difference they can in the world. I think that's the
commonality among all of us."
Some medical volunteers find that they can have the greatest impact by
training local doctors and improving their facilities. John Horstmann,
MD, a family practitioner in Colton, visits a 10-bed hospital in a poor
district of Tijuana once a month, outfitting it with supplies,
conducting training and trying to encourage greater collegiality. "When
I go down now, I don't see patients," Dr. Horstmann says. "My
involvement is in getting material. Redlands Community Hospital has
given us a number of things and Beaver Medical Group has given us a
defibrillator," he says. "I also help through medical education in the
hospital. I'm a wound-care specialist, so I've given some lectures."
Such seminars help to break through the difficult atmosphere prevailing
in the region and develop a collegial medical culture among local
doctors, he says.
Local doctors in host nations can also teach visiting U.S. physicians a
few things. "They train us how to do things with limited resources,"
Dr. Kukreja says. "A few things they do, we cannot even think of doing
here--that it is [even] possible--and they're doing it."
It's difficult to measure the impact of professional exchanges among
doctors across the globe, because proof of a job well done usually
comes in the form of an invitation to a family meal, a smile or a few
heartfelt words. Dr. Kukreja concludes: "You get e-mails back from the
local physicians and hear how much they appreciate what they learned
from you--but no numbers."
WE INVITE Your Comments. Share your feedback on this article. E-mail Chris Womack at chrisw@socalphys.com or call 213/226-0325.
---
FEATURE ARTICLE SIDEBAR
Organizations to Help You Help Out
There are plenty of U.S. medical volunteerism organizations that are
ready and willing to organize a trip for you. Here are several groups
affiliated with doctors interviewed for this article, or that have a
local connection.
Arpan Global Charities--Founded by Sudeep Kukreja, MD, organizes two to
three trips a year for a total of about 65 volunteers. Leans toward
pediatrics, but includes several specialists, especially surgeons and
physician educators.
E-mail: sudeepmd@yahoo.com
Phone: 714/585-1920
Web site: www.arpanglobal.org
International Relief Teams--With a focus on disaster relief, organizes
an average of 25 to 50 medical volunteers a year, serving more than 40
countries with supplies or personnel. With a recent greater interest in
neonatology, IRT also needs ophthalmologists, otolaryngologists,
anesthesiologists, primary care physicians, or whichever specialty a
particular disaster demands.
E-mail: info@irteams.org
Phone: 619/284-7979
Web site: www.irteams.org
Liga International--Responsible for sending about 650 to 700 medical
volunteers to Mexico and the Philippines every year. Needs family
practice physicians most, but encourages all types of doctors to
volunteer.
E-mail: pat@ligainternational.org
Phone: 909/875-6300
Web site: www.ligainternational.org
Operation Smile--Sends out approximately 4,000 volunteers a year to 25 countries. Focused on cleft lip and cleft palate surgery.
E-mail: credentialing@operationsmile.org
Phone: 888/677-6453
Web site: www.operationsmile.org
Orbis International--Organizes approximately 200 volunteers a year in
visits to 15 countries, particularly ophthalmologists, ophthalmic
nurses and biomedical engineers. Concentrates on glaucoma, causes of
childhood blindness, corneal transplants, cataracts and diabetic
retinopathy.
E-mail: sally.whitton@orbis.org
Phone: 305/829-0133
Web site: www.orbis.org
Project Vietnam--Organizes two expeditions a year to Vietnam for a total
of about 200 plastic surgeons, pediatricians and physician educators.
E-mail: qkieu@projectvietnam.net
Phone: 714/641-0850
Web site: www.projectvietnam.net
Surgical Eye Expeditions (SEE) International--Sends approximately 500
ophthalmologists to about 26 countries each year. Concentrates on
cataract surgeries.
E-mail: seeintl@seeintl.org
Phone: 805/963-3303
Web site: www.seeintl.org